As an owner getting ready for my exit, I could not have been luckier than to have Tom Howard as my business broker. Tom delivered on what mattered most to me. He grasped our business structure quickly, set and achieved a sale price in line with my expectations and our corporate financials, and brought in appropriate buyers. Tom is a seasoned, highly capable broker who is determined to meet the many challenges a business sale presents. The process was structured and transparent. At every stage Tom shared advice and a suite of contacts, which gave me access to skilled financial advisers, bankers, and qualified buyers. I would work with Tom on a future sale without hesitation.
Sell Your Insurance Agency
Insurance Agency Business Brokers & M&A Advisors
When an owner decides to sell an insurance agency, the asset a buyer really pays for is the renewal stream: the commissions that come back every year because clients keep their policies with you. DealPipe brokers and M&A advisors prove that stream in the terms an acquirer uses, by carrier, by line of business and by producer, so the price reflects retention you earned over many years. Independent property and casualty agencies, employee benefits firms, life and health shops, Medicare agencies and books of business all go through one confidential process. Your agency name is shared only after a buyer signs a nondisclosure agreement and documents the money to close, and your carriers and staff hear about the sale only when you decide.
Why Sell Your Insurance Agency With a Broker
Agency owners rarely have to look for buyers. Aggregators, regional brokers and neighboring agencies call often, and many arrive with a term sheet already drafted. The trouble with a single unsolicited offer is that it sets the price, the earn-out and the retention targets on the buyer’s terms, and you have nothing to compare it with.
We bring several qualified buyers to one package and one deadline. Before anyone sees it, we reconcile your agency management system to commission statements, separate new from renewal revenue, and adjust the books for owner pay and personal costs. Brokers such as Andrew Castaldy bring years in the financial services industry to that work. Our sell your business page walks through each stage of an engagement.
Insurance Agency Valuation: What Buyers Measure
Buyers usually start from recurring commission revenue or adjusted EBITDA, then move the multiple up or down based on how durable that revenue looks. Because agencies are often priced on a revenue basis, it helps to understand valuing a business based on revenue before the first call. The factors we document most carefully are:
- Retention. Policy and revenue retention by year and by line, not a single blended figure.
- Line mix. Commercial lines and employee benefits often attract more interest than small personal lines books, which face direct-to-consumer competition.
- Carrier relationships. Appointments, concentration with one carrier, and whether contracts allow the book to move with a sale.
- Contingent income. Profit-sharing and bonus commissions are shown separately, because buyers treat them as less predictable.
- Producer ties. Who owns each relationship, the age of key producers and whether non-solicitation agreements are in place.
Much of an agency’s price is goodwill, so it also helps to know how to calculate goodwill value and how a buyer will allocate it.
Independent Agencies, Books of Business and Advisory Practices We Sell
Ownership of the book shapes every deal, so we confirm it first. In most independent agency contracts, the agency owns its expirations and can sell them. Captive agents often hold a narrower interest that the carrier must approve, and some cannot sell their book at all.
- Independent property and casualty agencies, commercial and personal lines
- Employee benefits and group health agencies
- Life, health, Medicare and final expense agencies
- Specialty and program agencies serving one industry or niche
- Books of business sold separately from an agency
- Financial advisory and RIA practices with insurance or annuity revenue
For an advisory practice, plan early for client consent: federal rules generally require advisory contracts to bar assignment without it. If your company generates insurance leads instead of writing policies, read how we sell a lead generation business.
What Is Your Insurance Agency Worth?
Type in your revenue for the last twelve months and your total owner earnings, including your salary and any personal costs run through the agency. You will see an early range for your agency or book of business in a few seconds.
Your numbers
We value on your trailing twelve months, because that is what buyers underwrite. The prior full year sits beside it so we can read your growth. Round numbers are fine.
| Prior full yearCalendar 2025 | Trailing 12 monthsNov 2025 to Oct 2026 | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | ||
| less Cost of goods sold | ||
| less Operating expenses | ||
| equals Net profit | $0 | $0 |
| plus Add-backs | ||
| equals Seller’s Discretionary Earnings | $0 | $0 |
Add-backs are the expenses a new owner would not carry: your own salary, personal costs run through the business, one-time expenses, depreciation and interest. Adding them back to net profit gives SDE, the number buyers actually pay a multiple on.
What makes you valuable
0 selectedCheck everything that is true today. These are the levers that move your multiple up, and they count towards your estimate once your figures are in above.
Where the risk sits
0 selectedBe honest here. Buyers find these in diligence anyway, and knowing them up front is how we protect your price.
Your figures, and how we got this number
Get your insurance agency valuation report
The report we email lays out a likely range and how retention, line mix, carrier concentration and contingent commissions could shift it.
Results come from earnings multiples in business sales our brokers have handled. Treat the figure as an early estimate for planning, not a formal appraisal, a purchase offer, or tax, legal, regulatory or financial advice. Agency values depend on retention, carrier contracts, licensing and book ownership, so real offers can land above or below it.
Insurance Agency Exit Strategy and Succession Planning
Most agency buyers ask for three years of history, so succession planning works best when it starts well before you list. A year or two of clean, documented results is usually enough to change how buyers read your book.
- Clean up your system data. Make sure every policy, carrier and producer code in your agency management system matches commission statements.
- Track retention properly. Report policy count and revenue retention each year, by line.
- Secure producer agreements. Ask counsel about non-solicitation and book ownership terms for each producer.
- Reduce owner dependence. Move key commercial accounts to account managers who will stay after closing.
- Review carrier contracts. Note any approval rights, minimum volume rules or contingent agreements that a sale could affect.
- Gather compliance records. Keep license, appointment, continuing education and E&O claims history in one place.
The same preparation helps if you plan to retire through an internal perpetuation to a family member or a producer.
The Process
Book & Revenue Review
Confidential Buyer Outreach
Offers & Earn-Out Terms
Diligence & Transition
Talk to an Insurance Agency M&A Advisor
Who Buys Insurance Agencies Today
Insurance distribution is one of the most active corners of small business M&A. OPTIS Partners, which tracks announced agent and broker deals in North America, attributed roughly seven in ten of those deals in the first nine months of 2025 to private equity-backed buyers. Your realistic buyer list usually includes:
- Private equity-backed aggregators. Large brokers that buy agencies across many states and often offer rollover equity.
- Regional brokers. Firms adding a market, a specialty or commercial producers.
- Local independent agencies. Neighbors that can fold your clients into their own carrier panel.
- Individual buyers. Licensed agents and managers, often using SBA financing for smaller agencies.
- Internal successors. Producers or family members, usually paid over time.
Offers differ on cash at close, how much rides on retention and how long you stay. Buyers can browse current insurance and financial planning businesses for sale.
Our Insurance Agency Business Brokers
Recently Sold Insurance and Financial Services Businesses
Selling an Insurance Agency: FAQ
Your agency is usually valued as a multiple of recurring commission revenue or adjusted EBITDA. Retention, line mix, carrier concentration, growth and producer ties move the multiple up or down. Contingent commissions are often weighted less. A free business valuation gives you a starting range, and a broker review refines it with your actual book data.
Start by confirming that you own your book and can transfer it. Then reconcile three years of commission statements, document retention by line and review producer and carrier agreements. A broker prepares a confidential profile, screens buyers, compares offers and manages diligence, carrier approvals and the client transition through closing.
A typical agency sale takes six months to a year from launch to closing, plus any preparation time beforehand. Smaller books with clean data can move faster. Carrier approvals, licensing steps for the buyer, lender requirements and earn-out negotiations are the usual reasons a timeline stretches.
You can sell to a buyer who approached you, but you lose the leverage of competing offers and an independent view of the terms. An insurance agency broker brings several qualified buyers to the same deadline and checks earn-out targets carefully. Questions to put to any firm you interview are listed in how to choose a business broker.
DealPipe works on a 100% performance basis. Nothing is billed before a sale and there is no retainer to sign, and a success fee becomes payable only once your agency is sold. We walk through the precise fee arrangement for your agency in a free, confidential first call, ahead of any signed agreement.
Private equity-backed aggregators make many of the acquisitions, alongside regional brokers, local independent agencies, licensed individuals using SBA loans and internal successors such as producers or family members. Each values different things, from commercial lines growth to a ready-made client base in a new market, so a wide buyer list usually produces better terms.
A business broker typically handles smaller agencies and standalone books. Larger agencies with several producers, multiple offices or private equity interest often benefit from an M&A advisor who can run a structured auction and negotiate rollover equity. DealPipe provides each route, including full M&A advisory for larger agencies.
Not until you choose to tell them. Early buyer materials leave out your agency name, location and carrier list. Buyers see details only after signing an NDA and showing proof of funds. Carrier and staff conversations are planned together with you, usually late in the process, once a preferred buyer is in place.
Producer licenses belong to individuals, so the buyer needs properly licensed people and its own carrier appointments in your state. Some carriers must approve a transfer, and captive contracts can limit what you sell. Treat these as items to plan with qualified counsel and your carriers early; this is not legal advice.
More Industries We Serve